IT Outsourcing vs. In-House IT: Pros and Cons
As companies reach 25–75 employees, the question inevitably surfaces: hire an in-house IT person or outsource to a managed service provider? Here is an honest assessment.
In-House IT: Pros and Cons
Pros: - Dedicated resource who knows your business and culture - Immediate on-site availability during business hours - Can take ownership of strategic IT initiatives
Cons: - Fully-loaded annual cost of $75,000–$120,000 (salary + benefits + training + tools) - Single point of failure — vacations, sickness, resignation leave you uncovered - One person cannot provide 24/7 monitoring or after-hours emergency response - Depth of expertise is limited to one person's skill set - Hard to find candidates who are equally strong in networking, security, helpdesk, and strategic planning
Outsourced Managed IT: Pros and Cons
Pros: - Access to a team with diverse specializations (networking, security, VoIP, cloud) - 24/7 monitoring and after-hours emergency support - Predictable monthly cost ($100–$175 per user/month) - No single point of failure — if one technician is out, others cover - Included tools (RMM, EDR, backup, PSA) that would cost $20K+/year to license independently
Cons: - Less cultural familiarity (improved by good account management) - On-site response may be slower than someone sitting down the hall - Requires clear communication to keep the MSP aligned with business goals
The Hybrid Approach
Many mid-size businesses (50–200 employees) run a hybrid model: one internal IT director or manager for strategy and relationship management, with an MSP handling day-to-day monitoring, helpdesk, and security operations. This captures the benefits of both models.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: At what company size does in-house IT make financial sense?
A: Generally not until 75–100+ users, where the volume of support work justifies a fully-loaded IT salary. Below that threshold, managed IT delivers more capability per dollar.
Q: What if we already have an IT person?
A: Many businesses co-manage: the internal IT person handles strategic projects and vendor relationships while the MSP runs monitoring, patching, helpdesk, and security operations.
Q: How do you handle on-site emergencies if you are outsourced?
A: Summit DNC has field technicians throughout Southern California. On-site response for critical issues is typically available within 2–4 hours.
Q: Does outsourcing IT mean we lose control?
A: No. A good MSP provides complete transparency through client dashboards and monthly reporting. You retain decision authority over all IT investments and strategy.
Q: What happens when we want to bring IT in-house later?
A: A reputable MSP maintains complete documentation that transfers cleanly to an internal team. Summit DNC supports transition planning as clients grow.
Related Services
Related Comparisons
Industries We Serve
Related Articles
Business Continuity Planning for IT: Beyond Backup and Disaster Recovery
Learn why business continuity planning goes beyond backups, and how to build a comprehensive BCP that keeps your business running through any disruption.
Managed ITManaged IT vs. Break-Fix: Which Model Is Right for Your Business?
Compare managed IT services to break-fix support — cost analysis, response times, and which model fits different business sizes.
Managed ITWhat Is Remote Monitoring & Management (RMM)? A Business Owner's Guide
RMM software lets IT teams monitor, patch, and manage your entire network remotely. Learn how it works and why it matters for your business.
Need Help With Your Infrastructure Project?
Summit DNC designs and deploys the systems covered in this article. Contact us for a free consultation.